Main Content

Secondary peripheral chondrosarcoma, grades 2 and 3

Grade 2 and 3 secondary peripheral chondrosarcomas are intermediate-grade to high-grade malignant cartilaginous matrix–producing neoplasms originating at the surface of the bone in a pre-existing osteochondroma.

Symptoms & Causes

Introduction

Grade 2 and 3 secondary peripheral chondrosarcomas are malignant tumors that develop from pre-existing benign bone growths (osteochondromas), producing cartilage and ranging from intermediate to high grade in severity.

Reference
WHO Classification of Tumours Editorial Board. Soft tissue and bone tumours [Internet]. Lyon (France): International Agency for Research on Cancer; 2020 [cited 2024 09 11]. (WHO classification of tumours series, 5th ed.; vol. 3). Available from: https://tumourclassification.iarc.who.int/chapters/33.

Related Terminology
Not recommended: chondrosarcoma secondary to osteochondroma.

Subtype(s)
None

Symptoms

Enlargement or pain in a longstanding mass, especially after puberty, should raise suspicion for malignancy. Neurological symptoms and limited joint motion can be present.

Localization

These tumors most commonly arise in osteochondromas of the pelvis, trunk, and proximal femur.

Epidemiology

Grade 2 or 3 secondary peripheral chondrosarcomas are very rare (accounting for only ~9% of chondrosarcomas arising in osteochondroma) and arise mainly in patients aged 20–40 years.

Etiology

Patients with the multiple osteochondromas syndrome are at increased risk (~5%) of developing secondary peripheral chondrosarcoma within an osteochondroma. See section Multiple osteochondromas.

Diagnosis & Treatment

Staging

Staging is according to bone sarcoma protocols (see TNM staging of tumors of bone). See also the information on staging in the section Bone tumors: Introduction.

Pathogenesis

Whereas in secondary peripheral ACT/CS1, EXT-mutant cells and EXT-wildtype cells coexist, in high-grade secondary peripheral chondrosarcoma, the EXT-wildtype cells predominate. Similar to grade 2 and 3 central chondrosarcoma, these chondrosarcomas display chromosomal instability and a complex karyotype that increases with increasing histological grade, probably caused by alterations in the p53 and RB1 pathways.

Macroscopic Appearance

These lesions are translucent lobular bluish-white tumors in which there may be areas with myxoid material and cystic changes. The stalk of the pre-existing osteochondroma might still be recognized; the cap size exceeds 2 cm.

Histopathology

Grade 2 and 3 secondary peripheral chondrosarcomas are lobular cartilaginous matrix–producing tumors that are morphologically identical to grade 2 and 3 central chondrosarcomas. Sometimes areas of endochondral ossification suggestive of pre-existing osteochondroma can be seen. Nuclear pleomorphism and mitoses are often easily seen. At the periphery of the neoplastic cartilaginous lobules, spindle cell changes may occur. Coarse and irregular calcification, binucleated cells, cystic change, and necrosis can be observed.

Immunohistochemistry
These tumours can be positive for S100.

Grading
Criteria for histological grading are identical to those for grade 2 and 3 central chondrosarcoma.

Differential diagnosis
Periosteal osteosarcoma is included in the differential diagnosis. Peripheral chondrosarcoma is separated from central chondrosarcoma based on its location at the surface of the bone.

Cytology

Not clinically relevant.

Prognosis and Prediction

Local recurrences can occur, generally related to incomplete excision. The majority of patients who die of their disease have local recurrence.

Clinical Features

Diagnostic Molecular Pathology

Molecular analysis is rarely needed for diagnosis. Mutations in IDH1, IDH2, and NRAS are absent.

Essential and Desirable Diagnostic Criteria

Essential: chondrosarcoma arising in a pre-existing osteochondroma or with evidence of the stalk of a precursor osteochondroma; cartilage cap exceeds 2 cm; mitoses and nuclear pleomorphism are present.

ribbon

Make a Donation

Help us move closer to a world where people do not die from sarcoma

Make a Donation
ribbon

section